Posted On Dec 30, 2024

The journey towards homeownership in Canada, especially for first-time buyers, has become increasingly daunting due to soaring property prices and stringent financing conditions. In response, the federal government and some provincial administrations have implemented changes aimed at easing this path. But do these measures address the underlying challenges, or are they simply surface-level fixes? In this analysis, we examine the recent updates, their tangible impacts, and whether they truly deliver meaningful progress—or merely serve as political posturing ahead of an election.

 

Recent Changes impacting First-Time Home Buyers

1. Increased Withdrawal Limits from the RRSP First-Time Home Buyers' Plan

The withdrawal limit under the RRSP First-Time Home Buyers' Plan has been increased from $35,000 to $60,000. This change allows individuals to access a larger pool of tax-free funds to assemble a down payment—a crucial boost in an era where upfront costs are a significant barrier. While this move provides greater financial flexibility, its benefit is contingent on prospective buyers having sufficient savings in their RRSPs, a challenge for many younger Canadians facing stagnant wages and rising living costs.

2. Adjustments to Mortgage Insurance and Amortization Rules

  • Increased Price cap for insured mortgages:  The price cap for insured mortgages has increased from $1 million to $1.5 million, theoretically enabling buyers in high-cost markets like Toronto and Vancouver to purchase homes with a minimum 5% (and up to a max 20%) down payment.

  • Eligibility for extended 30-year amortizations:  All first-time homebuyers and anyone purchasing new construction are eligible for an insured mortgage with a 30-year amortization. While this reduces monthly payments, it also increases the total interest paid over the loan’s term.

3. Enhancements to the First Home Savings Account (FHSA)

Launched in 2023, the FHSA is a tax-advantaged savings vehicle designed to help Canadians save for their first home. Recent enhancements in 2024 raised the annual contribution limit to $8,000, with a lifetime cap of $40,000. Contributions are tax-deductible, and investment growth within the account is tax-free, provided the funds are used for a qualifying home purchase.

 

 

The Real Impact of These Changes

While the updates aim to make homeownership more accessible, their effectiveness in addressing the broader housing affordability crisis is widely debated.

Superficial Solutions or Genuine Impact?

Critics argue that the measures may offer short-term relief without tackling the root causes of unaffordability. Increasing the insured mortgage cap and extending amortization periods, for instance, might help more people enter the market—but at what cost? These changes could inflate demand, exacerbating housing price growth, particularly in high-demand urban areas.

The FHSA’s utility is also limited by Canadians' ability to save amid high inflation and stagnant wage growth. While it incentivizes disciplined saving, it doesn't address the structural barriers to affordability, such as insufficient housing supply.

Election-Driven Motives?

Some observers see these measures as politically motivated, timed to win favor with voters ahead of the next federal election. By appearing proactive on housing, the government garners goodwill without making the hard policy choices needed for long-term solutions. For example, the lack of robust measures to increase affordable housing supply suggests a reluctance to challenge systemic issues like zoning laws or encourage more aggressive development of multi-family units.

Missed Opportunities

While the updates focus on demand-side solutions, they neglect pressing supply-side concerns. Policies to incentivize affordable housing construction, streamline development approvals, or provide grants to municipalities for densification could yield more sustainable impacts. Without addressing supply constraints, these changes risk fueling a cycle where higher purchasing power simply drives up prices.

 

Addressing the Skilled Trades Shortage: A Key to Increasing Housing Supply

A critical factor in alleviating housing supply constraints is addressing the shortage of skilled tradespeople essential for construction and development.

The Role of Immigration in the Skilled Trades

Canada has recognized the importance of immigration in filling labor shortages in the skilled trades. However, only a small fraction of immigrants enter Canada with qualifications in these areas. For instance, the Federal Skilled Trades Program, designed to attract such workers, has modest targets and stringent requirements, resulting in limited admissions.

The Hub

Retirement and the Aging Workforce

The skilled trades sector faces significant challenges due to an aging workforce. Projections estimate that approximately 700,000 skilled trades workers are expected to retire between 2019 and 2028, creating an urgent need to recruit and train thousands more.

Canada.ca

Government Initiatives and Apprenticeship Programs

To address these challenges, the Canadian government has implemented several initiatives:

  • Financial Support for Apprenticeships: Programs like the Apprenticeship Incentive Grant and the Apprenticeship Completion Grant provide financial assistance to apprentices in Red Seal trades, offering up to $4,000 in grants.
    Canada.ca

  • Promotion of Skilled Trades Careers: Campaigns aim to rebrand skilled trades as viable and lucrative career paths for youth and underrepresented groups, including women and Indigenous peoples.
    Canada.ca

  • Support for Employers: Initiatives like the Apprenticeship Service provide financial incentives to small and medium-sized enterprises to hire new apprentices, particularly from underrepresented groups.
    Canada.ca

Despite these efforts, apprenticeship programs face challenges, including societal stigmas and insufficient promotion at the educational level. While government support exists, more robust and coordinated efforts are necessary to elevate the perception of skilled trades and streamline pathways into these careers.

 

What’s Missing?

Housing experts widely agree that more ambitious reforms are required to alleviate Canada's affordability crisis. Key suggestions include:

  • Promoting Supply Growth: Encouraging the construction of affordable homes, especially in urban areas, to meet rising demand.

  • Property Tax Reforms: Adjusting tax structures to favor first-time buyers or penalize speculative real estate investments.

  • Direct Subsidies for Low-Income Households: Providing targeted financial support to those who struggle most with housing costs.

Additionally, the federal Conservative Party recently proposed eliminating the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on newly constructed homes priced under $1 million. Proponents argue that this measure could reduce the cost of an $800,000 home by approximately $40,000, making homeownership more attainable for first-time buyers. They also suggest it could stimulate the construction of an additional 30,000 homes annually, addressing supply shortages.

Yahoo News

Such measures could complement existing incentives, ensuring that the benefits of homeownership are not eroded by market pressures.

 

Conclusion: A Step Forward or Treading Water?

The recent updates to first-time home buyer incentives reflect a government keen to demonstrate action on housing affordability. While they offer immediate benefits—such as increased purchasing power and enhanced savings options—their long-term impact remains uncertain. Without tackling systemic issues like housing supply and the skilled trades shortage, these measures risk being undermined by rising demand and escalating prices.

For first-time buyers, these changes may represent a lifeline in the short term. However, achieving true affordability will require bold, comprehensive reforms that address the housing market's structural challenges. As the election approaches, Canadians must ask whether these updates

Let's connect!

Ready to discuss your home ownership goals and a Better Mortgage by Dom?

 

«